Monday, July 11, 2016

The Fallacy of Amphiboly

The fallacy of amphiboly is, like the fallacy of equivocation, a fallacy of ambiguity, but here the ambiguity is due to indeterminate syntactic structure. In the argument:
The police were told to stop drinking on campus after midnight.
So, now they are able to respond to emergencies much better than before.
there are several interpretations that can be given to the premise because it is grammatically ambiguous. On one reading it can be taken to mean that it is the police who have been drinking and are now to stop it; this makes for a plausible argument. On another reading what was meant is that the police were told to stop others (e.g., students) from drinking after midnight. If that is the sense in which the premise is intended, then the argument can be said to be a fallacy because despite initial appearances, it affords no support for the conclusion.
This was really interesting to me. I initially read and understood the passage as the police were the ones who needed to stop consuming the drinks after midnight, and therefore, they would be better able to respond to emergencies. I didn't realize that it could have been understood as the police needed to go patrolling and stop other people from drinking after midnight. So that instead of having to respond to a lot of incidents involving drunken people on campus, they can focus on other emergencies that may arise. Very interesting. How did yall interpret the passage?
Sabrina Oakes

Thursday, July 7, 2016

The Fallacy of Equivocation


craigssenseofwonder.wordpress.com

The fallacy of equivocation occurs when a vague statement is used many times during an argument but has different meaning each time. For example, the fallacy above says that noisy children are a "headache", which is our vague statement. Our vague statement comes up again when it is said that aspirin will make a "headache" go away. It is fallacious to equate these two terms to each other because they were used in different contexts. The first context is metaphorical and uses the term headache to describe how difficult noisy children can be; the second is more literal, referring to a physical ache.

Hansen, Hans. "Fallacies." Stanford University. Stanford University, 29 May 2015. Web. 07 July 2016.

Thursday, June 30, 2016

Slippery Slope Examples

The Slippery Slope is the idea that when something happens another event will occur due to the previous one. It is a chain reaction and really no explanation as to why it happens. The Nizkor Project has a good idea to the explanation of what the Slippery Slope equation looks like, "This "argument" has the following form: 
1. Event X has occurred (or will or might occur). 
2. Therefore event Y will inevitably happen."
It is interesting to think about how something happens because of something else. There are a lot of examples in life that can agree with this idea. Some of the examples I found it does not make sense as to why these events happen because of something else. I believe this comic is a good example because it shows how by doing one thing it prevents bad things from happening. The Slippery Slope can be thought of as something you do to avoid other things. A lot of the examples can be negative, but there can also be positive ideas as well.  











Links:
http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/slippery-slope.html
http://pactiss.org/2008/09/09/slippery-slope-cartoon/ 

Wednesday, June 29, 2016

Slippery Slope

An example of a slippery slope fallacy is a supervisor at a company wants to let his employees personalize their work space, and be able to use the internet for certain research and on their breaks.  But, the owner of the company says, "no way."  She believes that if she lets them put up pictures of family then eventually inappropriate pictures will be hung on the wall and harassment lawsuits will be filed.  She also says that the company will fold if employees are allowed to have internet access because their productivity will go down and the company will suffer.  These are large leaps to take from the initial requests from the supervisor.

http://study.com/academy/lesson/slippery-slope-fallacy-definition-examples.html

Logical Fallacies in advertising

Through researching logical fallacies I realized that in today's society, logical fallacies are everywhere. I decided to research logical fallacies in advertisements because it shows how we are influenced by these logical fallacies on a daily basis.
Slippery slope:
 
Allstate teenage girl commercial:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vtP-S9OS0o0
This is slippery slope because the driver is a teenage girl it will inevitably lead to a car accident.
Appeal to celebrity:
 Image result for drake sprite
Drake supporting sprite:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0nBxcMImubk
Commericals use celebrities constantly based on the logical fallacy that if a celebrity uses a product, you should too.

Commercials use a variety of logical fallacies which we as consumers can uncover to not get influenced in buying a product based on a fallacy.

Fallacies

The Purdue OWL has some fantastic examples of fallacies. One category of those are Ignorantio Elenchi fallacies, or Irrelevant Conclusions. A subtype of this is the Straw Man fallacy, which oversimplifies the opponent's viewpoint and then attacks that hollow view. For example,
People who don't support the proposed state minimum wage hate the poor. 
I competed in collegiate policy debate my first semester of college and this was absolutely the most frustrating sort of argumentation, because an effective straw man makes the opponent look ignorant if they are unable to recognize the fallacy and combat it. The name of the fallacy explains why it is so frustrating to be a victim of this false logic. A professor from Carson-Newman University explained it this way: the straw man comes from the idea of a boxer fashioning an opponent out of straw and then easily knocking it over in the ring before a cheering audience. His victory; of course, "is a hollow mockery, because the straw-stuffed opponent is incapable of fighting back". An opponent who uses this kind of logic can have the same effect, making you feel like a straw person with no ability to fight back. Like this comic illustrates, no matter what side of an argument you present in the face of a straw man you are wrong, and stupid to boot.

Comic from http://stripgenerator.com/strip/589005/click-clack-straw-man/

Tuesday, June 28, 2016

New Blog Topic



Thank you all for your thoughtful and interesting contributions to the previous blog topic. I found it very interesting, and I learned a lot!

If you have more to post on the previous topic, or if you've not posted yet, you still can, anytime. Consider that topic an open one...

Meanwhile, let's take up a new topic. We will soon turn our attention to logic, and along with it, the question of a type of argument known as a "logical fallacy." A logical fallacy is an argument that might be true, or it might not be...or it might, or not...but the argument does not present enough information to decide whether it's true or false, BUT the argument is persuasive.

We will study some of these logical fallacies in the next week or two. They include arguments like the argumentum ad absurdum - an argument used by both Socrates (or Plato, at least) and Zeno (the disciple of Parmenides). Another fallacy is the slippery slope argument: this event will lead to this next event, which will lead to this next event, and then APOCALYPSE! In both fallacies just mentioned, the problem is that it might be true, or it might not be true, but we don't have enough evidence to decide one way or another. In the case of an argumentum ad absurdum, the one absurd consequence that results from the argument or definition does not prove that all consequences are absurd. To make the stronger claim (that the definition or argument is absurd), we need more evidence. Likewise, in a slippery slope argument, it might be that 'A' will lead to 'B', and 'B' to 'C,' and so forth, but it might not, therefore, we need more information.

Okay, enough theory. I want you to "research" a bit about logical fallacies, and then post some examples of the fallacies you find. Wikipedia is a (bad) starting point, but I recommend using the Stanford Online Encyclopedia of Philosophy, or the Online Encyclopedia of Philosophy (from the University of Tennessee, I believe). If you need other sources, please let me know.

One more 'hint': there are a number of books of fallacies, including Jeremy Bentham's Handbook of Political Fallacies. Feel free to be creative. I recently encountered a fallacy I didn't know the name of (never heard of it before). In a text I was reading, the author presented a metaphor for something in one paragraph, and in the next paragraph, took the metaphor as if it was fact. I don't even know what that fallacy is called, yet.

Rhetoric = the art of persuasion.
Persuasion can be used to convince people of the true or the false.
Therefore, it can be used by unscrupulous people for their purposes.
But remember, rhetoric, like fallacies, might be true, or not...or....